1) A six foot tree with a thin stem and a sturdy treeshelter in place to support it until the stem thickens up enough to support itself is a whole lot better than the alternative: A seedling without a tube that is continually browse by deer to the point where it dies or is stunted at knee height for years.
2) Today's vented tree tubes and flexible PVC stakes have combine to make a myth out of the "spindly stem" critique of tree tubes. Thin stems are a thing of the distant past. Take a look:
(Click to enlarge)
This is the trunk of a hybrid oak from Mossy Oak Nativ Nurseries planted in a 4ft Tubex Combitube Plus Tree Tube. Here's the chronology:
* Planted as 18 inch seedling in March, 2011
* Photo taken on August 2, 2012 - less than two complete growing seasons later!
The tree is now well over 10ft tall. But most exciting to me is the large caliper of the trunk immediately above the tree tube. You can see that with today's vented tree tubes and flexible PVC stakes it's not just a matter of producing the same amount of biomass growth and just "stretching" it in height, as might have been the case with early tree tubes. No, this tree is putting on a HUGE amount of total biomass (especially when you consider that stem diameter is the best "window" into what's going on with root growth below ground).
As with so many discussions of tree tubes it comes down to B.V. (Before Venting) and A.V. (After Venting). Before venting trees were definitely better off with tree tubes than without, but exhibited some "side effects" like thin stems. After venting tree planters are realizing the full potential of tree tubes and seeing astounding growth, both in terms of height but - more importantly - in terms of stem diameter.
Think of it this way, using a computer analogy: Unvented, small diameter tubes of the past = MS-DOS. Today's vented, large diameter tubes combined with flexible PVC stakes = Windows XP.
No comments:
Post a Comment